the pie tin shredded pork pie

The Pie Tin, Newtown

Sydney’s best pie?

Noodlies, Sydney food blog samples a popular Newtown icon

We love ‘best of” lists and noodlies is no stranger to these quests having conducted Sydney’s best pho in 2010 and then Sydney’s best pork roll last year.

In case you didn’t know it, the choice is always subjective based on a person’s tastes and predilections. And so, when asked, I cautiously accept the potentially contentious commission of being  SBS Feast Food Awards NSW judge (again).

the pie tin shredded pork pie

Around noon on a crispy and sunny Sydney day, I am faced with this – slow roasted shredded pork with apple & bbq sauce from Newtown’s The Pie Tin. It’s a handsome, traditional-looking pie (in contrast to the flakier ones from Black Star Pastry down the road). And sturdy too, dense with sweet, melting pork – the filling covers every nook and cranny of the tall pastry. And of course, The Pie Tin pies are served up in homely tin plates.

the pie tin pies

All the pies are made on the premises and there’s a bewildering choice – over 20 savoury pies, traditional to modern, multicultural executions: classic mince, chicken leek, chunky steak, slow roasted beef brisket, North African roasted lamb, cajun style pork, even chicken carbonara.

the pie tin newtown

The decor is rustic, farm-yard-authentic consistent with the traditional, generous pies; naked brick walls, large windows with a giant, sturdy communal table as centre-piece.

pie tin dessert cakes

There’s sweet pies too, here there’s even more to choose from – the strawberry and cream as well as date & walnut butterscotch rustic pies catch my eye, but alas there’s no room after the belly-busting shredded pork pie. Those wanting something different might think about indulging in a slice or two of the sticky date pudding or oreo cookie pies.

Oh, and you want to know if The Pie Tin takes out the title of NSW’s best pie? My advice is to get a copy of the September issue of SBS Feast magazine, out early August.

For now, my lips are sealed.

The Pie Tin
1a Brown St, Newtown (off King St)
(02) 9519 7880

The Pie Tin on Urbanspoon

There are 12 comments

Add yours
  1. beth

    it’s hands-down the best pie in sydney. amazing flavours like triple choc brownie or peanut butter pie, and great value for money. a firm favorite.

  2. Annie @ The Random Foodie

    love the pies here. cannot get enough of them. though last time we were there, we left the ordering for the dessert pies too late so by the time we finished the savoury pies, most of them have sold out. going back there tonight though 🙂

  3. Vivian - vxdollface

    pies glorious pies! i still haven’t had the pleasure of stopping by yet but I’ve been meaning to for a while now >< whenever i'm in newtown, i find it hard to stray away from black star pastry ^^"

  4. Melly

    Man, do those pies look good. I’ve been meaning to check this place out – I reckon it’s pretty good compared to the others (Harrys, Black, etc). Actually saw another review of Pie Tin in this article ( which is actually what brought me here! I’ve heard good things about it, and wanted to do some further research about what they look like. Cheers for sharing your experience!

Leave a Reply